| Rank | Player | ID | Win-Loss |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Keith Elwin | 1038 | 86 - 34 |
| 2 | Andrew Rosa II | 322 | 85 - 35 |
| Jim Belsito | 296 | 85 - 35 | |
| 4 | Daniele Celestino Acciari | 591 | 84 - 36 (tied for double bye) |
| Aaron Grabowski | 776 | 84 - 36 (tied for double bye) | |
| 6 | Andy Rosa | 208 | 80 - 40 |
| Colin Macalpine | 398 | 80 - 40 | |
| Raymond Davidson | 892 | 80 - 40 | |
| Cryss Stephens | 422 | 80 - 40 | |
| 10 | Eric Stone | 259 | 79 - 41 |
| David Riel | 932 | 79 - 41 | |
| Zach Sharpe | 657 | 79 - 41 | |
| Keith Johnson | 838 | 79 - 41 | |
| 14 | Joseph Lemire | 371 | 78 - 42 |
| 15 | Andrei Massenkoff | 332 | 77 - 43 |
| Cayle George | 798 | 77 - 43 | |
| 17 | Drew Cedolia | 342 | 76 - 44 |
| Steve Hill | 1027 | 76 - 44 | |
| Jason Werdrick | 701 | 76 - 44 | |
| Germain Mariolle | 331 | 76 - 44 | |
| 21 | Brian O'Neill | 665 | 75 - 45 |
| Derek Price | 816 | 75 - 45 | |
| Eric Destasio | 515 | 75 - 45 | |
| 24 | Jordan Dechaine | 118 | 74 - 46 |
| John Delzoppo | 540 | 74 - 46 | |
| Elliott Keith | 284 | 74 - 46 | |
| Daniel Rone | 726 | 74 - 46 | |
| 28 | Austin Trent | 210 | 73 - 47 |
| Ben Granger | 1083 | 73 - 47 | |
| Adam Lefkoff | 780 | 73 - 47 | |
| Timothy Street | 1075 | 73 - 47 | |
| Karl Deangelo | 335 | 73 - 47 | |
| Escher Lefkoff | 559 | 73 - 47 | |
| 34 | Timothy Enders Previous: 69-39, 61-35, 53-31, 45-27, 42-18, 34-14, 26-10, 19-5, 10-2, seed 87 | 705 | 72 - 48 (advanced to finals) |
| Richie Terry Previous: 68-40, 61-35, 52-32, 42-30, 37-23, 29-19, 21-15, 14-10, 8-4, seed 61 | 837 | 72 - 48 (advanced to finals) | |
| Jens Flügge Previous: 67-41, 57-39, 50-34, 42-30, 33-27, 28-20, 17-19, 16-8, 9-3, seed 32 | 1042 | 72 - 48 (advanced to finals) | |
| John Miller Previous: 66-42, 55-41, 46-38, 41-31, 30-30, 24-24, 22-14, 17-7, 11-1, seed 115 | 974 | 72 - 48 (advanced to finals) | |
| Aleksander Kaczmarczyk Previous: 65-43, 58-38, 51-33, 43-29, 40-20, 29-19, 21-15, 16-8, 8-4, seed 13 | 174 | 72 - 48 (advanced to finals) | |
| Steven Bowden Previous: 65-43, 57-39, 51-33, 41-31, 34-26, 28-20, 22-14, 14-10, 7-5, seed 5 | 725 | 72 - 48 (advanced to finals) | |
| Andrew Foster Previous: 65-43, 55-41, 50-34, 43-29, 36-24, 33-15, 27-9, 19-5, 10-2, seed 86 | 914 | 72 - 48 (advanced to finals) | |
| Joe Said Previous: 65-43, 54-42, 50-34, 43-29, 38-22, 29-19, 21-15, 16-8, 7-5, seed 215 | 366 | 72 - 48 (did not advance) | |
| Jason Zahler Previous: 64-44, 58-38, 50-34, 43-29, 31-29, 29-19, 26-10, 15-9, 6-6, seed 31 | 255 | 72 - 48 (did not advance) | |
| Josh Sharpe Previous: 64-44, 57-39, 48-36, 42-30, 40-20, 30-18, 27-9, 16-8, 9-3, seed 26 | 553 | 72 - 48 (did not advance) | |
| Derek Thomson Previous: 64-44, 55-41, 47-37, 40-32, 38-22, 35-13, 27-9, 19-5, 12-0, seed 42 | 534 | 72 - 48 (did not advance) |