| Rank | Player | ID | Win-Loss |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Keith Elwin | 281 | 93 - 27 |
| 2 | Colin MacAlpine | 246 | 84 - 36 |
| Donavan Stepp | 497 | 84 - 36 | |
| 4 | Josh Sharpe | 601 | 83 - 37 |
| 5 | Adam Becker | 341 | 81 - 39 |
| Andrei Massenkoff | 314 | 81 - 39 | |
| Trent Augenstein | 158 | 81 - 39 | |
| Eric Stone | 830 | 81 - 39 | |
| 9 | Andy Rosa | 740 | 78 - 42 |
| Zach Sharpe | 228 | 78 - 42 | |
| Jack Tadman | 592 | 78 - 42 | |
| Jerry Bernard | 356 | 78 - 42 | |
| 13 | Jim Belsito | 647 | 77 - 43 |
| Levi Nayman | 871 | 77 - 43 | |
| 15 | Aleksander Kaczmarczyk | 866 | 76 - 44 |
| Karl DeAngelo | 178 | 76 - 44 | |
| 17 | Steven Zahler | 251 | 75 - 45 |
| Lyman Sheats | 553 | 75 - 45 | |
| Jason Scheffelmaer | 829 | 75 - 45 | |
| Adam McKinnie | 265 | 75 - 45 | |
| Derek Miazga | 312 | 75 - 45 | |
| 22 | Cayle George | 134 | 74 - 46 |
| Brian O'Neill | 301 | 74 - 46 | |
| David Oliver | 709 | 74 - 46 | |
| Sebastian Bobbio | 391 | 74 - 46 | |
| Escher Lefkoff | 133 | 74 - 46 | |
| Gregory Galanter | 113 | 74 - 46 | |
| Dave Stewart | 499 | 74 - 46 | |
| Zac Wollons | 118 | 74 - 46 | |
| 30 | Timothy Street | 733 | 73 - 47 |
| Raymond Davidson | 462 | 73 - 47 | |
| Zachary Frey | 127 | 73 - 47 | |
| Al Thomka | 184 | 73 - 47 | |
| Matthew Schwab | 853 | 73 - 47 | |
| Howard Levine | 459 | 73 - 47 | |
| Luke Nahorniak | 404 | 73 - 47 | |
| Eric C Ramey | 234 | 73 - 47 | |
| Gabe da Silveira | 399 | 73 - 47 | |
| 39 | Derek Thomson | 212 | 72 - 48 (tied and advanced) |
| Arthur Dodd | 147 | 72 - 48 (tied and advanced) | |
| Rod Lawrence | 376 | 72 - 48 (did not advance) | |
| Drew Donohue | 734 | 72 - 48 (did not advance) | |
| Scott Wilson | 260 | 72 - 48 (did not advance) | |
| Robert Byers | 477 | 72 - 48 (did not advance) | |
| Mark Meserve | 815 | 72 - 48 (did not advance) | |
| Johnny Modica | 699 | 72 - 48 (did not advance) | |
| Evan Bingham | 177 | 72 - 48 (did not advance) |